Why Does Will Think It Is Unlikely That Adnan Was Late For Track, According to Jay and the prosecution at trial, why would Adnan call Jay for help with the crime? (18:30) Adnan would call Jay for help with the crime because Jay had experience … I don't think this makes Adnan ego driven or narcissistic, as I believe most humans feel this way. Asia saw him at the library and stands by that memory even today. Anyway, I don't think that's the important thing here. Given it being a rare occasion that people were late to track, you would think that Will would remember if Adnan had been … Why does Adnan believe it would have been impossible for him to have killed Hae in that particular 21-minute window? The school bell rings at 2:15 and with 1500 other students in a … So, in Serial's episode 5, Sarah mentions that back in 2013, a year before Serial airs, Adnan writes in his letter to Sarah that he thinks it'd be "impossible" to make The Route To Best Buy in 21 minutes. In Baltimore, January 13th, 1999, a … From a psychological perspective, I think "Why doesn’t Adnan remember the day he narrowly escaped being murdered?" is a completely valid - and further, interesting - question. Adnan's reaction is … View Serial-Episode-10. You… Study with Quizlet and memorize flashcards containing terms like What does Saad (Adnan's friend) offer as evidence that Adnan was not upset by the breakup?, Who is Sa'ad?, What does the prosecution … People believed that Adnan's case was influenced by racism. No amount of phone records or incorrect testimonies necessitate he did it. How does he tell the story? What does he think about it now that he is an adult? Adnan is ashamed that he had done such a thing in his religion though he doesn't think it's a big deal … I think this tilts the scale strongly towards Jay telling the truth about the conversation taking place that day and Nisha just messed up that detail or Adnan told her Jay was working there for whatever reason. Neither have been 99% of kids ever. What is the crucial time window that Adnan cannot account for? 21 minutes. Jay's story can change 50 times but at … 1. Why does this look bad for Adnan? It looks bad for Adnan because the cell tower data places his phone near Leakin Park at the time of Hae’s burial, supporting Jay’s account. Adnan's father and another person at the mosque … 3 Evidence and Source How it supports the motive Why it could be unimportant to the case/ fails to support the motive Overall, is the evidence valuable ? Accounts of Adnan's reaction to the break up … I think that was a shortcoming of the defense, as while obviously not required, it typically does go further with a jury in a murder trial to hear at least some semblance of an alternative theory. He was … Why lie about such simple things? Did they think that no one would look at a map? Did Rabia seriously think the burial site was an hour from the high school? How many other things in the defense file contradict what Adnan said on Serial? (The … Memory Challenge: Sarah Koenig says it is difficult to account for our time in a detailed way. 8. m. It's exhausting how people don't consider how they'd interpret the things if Adnan reacted like they think he should. … But even so, that means if Adnan still had to get changed, he is very late for four p. Episode 9: To Be Suspected As the podcast … 4pm Track practice: Adnan says he probably attended track practice, but the he and coach couldn’t remember. ) People were shocked that Adnan got arrested … But even so, that means if Adnan still had to get changed, he is very late for four p. He is clearly with Jay till just after 8pm. You might think that makes me equivalent to a 9/11 Truther or moon-landing-was-faked theorist. In another version, Adnan says it a week prior to the … View Serial_Episode_05__transcript_. Jay does not seem to be part of his Magnet Friends, or Mosque friends. Koeng thinks that it might have contributed … How might this relate to Adnan? (8:30) What does Enright think about the state’s case against Adnan? Koenig asks, “but isn’t the fact that they did put him away mean they had enough to put him away?” … For those who think he’s guilty, which is many of you, how dumb do you think Adnan was to turn down that offer? Did his lawyers really brainwash/talk him against to taking the deal? How do you seriously … Episode 1: Serial Podcast focuses on narrator Sarah Koenig exploring the murder case of Hae Min Lee. We … I think the only really honest way to deal with Kristi's account of his behaviour if you are pro-innocent is to either just not really care about how someone "appears" and to not psychoanalyse them, or think … I think at this point it's been established Hae went missing and was killed between 3-3:30 that day, which would have been the same time Adnan would have been at track or at the library. He may have been an accomplice of … 2. On January 13, 1999, Hae went … Study with Quizlet and memorize flashcards containing terms like What is the crucial time window that Adnan cannot account for?, who is rabia and why is she important, how is Baltimore described by … Sarah informed Adnan that she had discovered Asia and then left it at that. It just eliminates one of the main defenses of him, that he was this … 12 votes, 79 comments. Rabia contacts Sarah Koenig, who begins to investigate … I too thought that Adnan must be innocent, otherwise why would the podcast exist? I don't particularly believe so anymore, but I also think this was a valuable journey. She asks because it differs from Jay’s story a bit and she wants to know what really happened that … What do you think of Adnan’s reaction to Koenig’s news about Asia? Hopeless, heart breaking, I wish she would have come to this realization, it's too late, I feel like Jay killed Hae and threw Adnan under the bus for it. Jay agree's, not wanting to be a punk and back down, but also doubting Adnan will go through with it. I know I had plenty of business to attend to between classes, even when I was just going down the hall. For some reason people keep pretending that he didn't. Move her death later to account for this, and you … Why does Koenig ask this? What does it lead the listener to think? Makes people think that Adnan and Stephanie have something going for them. What does Koenig think? (5:30) Koenig thinks that Adnan's case wasn't too influenced by racism. The day coach Sye describes is likely the day of the crime given the weather circumstances, the end of … It could have been done without Jay is the op’s point. However, after listening to all of the evidence and I just couldn’t accept that Jay told everyone all those bullshit to get himself into trouble when in fact Adnan didn’t do it, I was convinced that Adnan is … It was as much a community center as it was a place of worship. Do you think there is a basis for this … 4. This happens after Hae’s murder. There is a map found in Hae's car with the Adnan's palm print on it. 5. Why is the hour before track … 7. ) Because he was nice, active, "the golden child" Answer: He was an honor … Study with Quizlet and memorize flashcards containing terms like What piece of evidence does Sarah utilize in her investigation?, According to Hae's diary, how does Hae feel about Adnan and his … Adnan calls Jan. Why does the judge in … Adnan goes out of his way to make himself noticed at track practice by having a long conversation with the coach. I think Adnan then walked to a nearby pay phone to call Jay and get him to pick him up from the BB. ) Because he was nice, active, "the golden child" Answer: He was an honor roll student, volunteered EMT. Why does Koenig ask … Route Part 2: After Murder- Before Track (15:00) 4. There's been a lot of speculation on why Adnan was calling Hae around midnight on Jan. He sets a very strong narrative that they weren’t close, and acts almost surprised that Jay would be saying these things. 14. Having everyone look down on you is a horrible feeling, but it has obviously controlled Adnan for his entire … But Adnan did have alibis. Speaking about the Asia letter, Adnan says this in the 2nd paragraph of the last page: “I don’t believe it’s so far-fetched to think … I think that there are legitimate questions in this case based on my reading of the available evidence. Why does Rabia (the lawyer from the beginning of the episode) think Adnan did NOT do it? Make a list of reasons. … Will thinks its unlikely that Adnan was late for track because its common that he’s always View Episode_1__The_Alibi. Episode Ten: The Best Defense is a Good Defense Name: Date: 1. Given Adnan’s insistence that only … Sarah asks why Adnan cares if Jay got Stephanie a present. He is innocent because … 4. The important thing is that Adnan says … This episode dealt with the arguably most important character to this story, Jay. 1:15AM Approx: Stephanie calls Adnan as he drives Becky home. Rabia asks about taking the case due to problems with Adnan's lawyer, Middle … I think the simplest answer to this is would be 'Adnan knew it could be done, but he had a fresh new audience willing to believe his innocence, and he threw everything he could think of to get her to … At the trial, Adnan’s track coach says practice ran from about 4:00 p. She remembered Adnan telling her that Jay invited him over to where Jay works in evening There are a lot of holes in the case like Jay not working at the video store at the time, the … At a minimum, that means Jay has Adnan's cell (and presumably car) until late into the evening, which is odd since he supposedly only borrowed it to buy a birthday present for Stephanie early in the day. 2. Given Adnan’s insistence that only … This does not cause anger in Adnan and he and Hae remain friends. Sarah asks why Adnan cares if Jay has Stephanie get a present. With Serial, I wasn't sure Adnan was innocent but I could not have convicted him based on the evidence as I heard … Why does Adnan claim in Serial that he never would have asked Hae for a ride after school because she never would have said yes due to needing to pick up her cousin? We know this is blatantly false. 3 Episode 10: The Best Defense is a good Defense f Adnan’s Appeal: IRL 19. For me, the first thing that made me start to question Adnan’s story was why he was even intertwined with Jay that day. What does Adnan say about his parents’ perspective of his relationship with Hae? His parents were really good friends with Hae’s parents, so they were happy about the connection. She said she talked to Adnan at the library during the time Hae was killed. It showed who Adnan truly was as Sarah proved that the people … 7. trueAs a caveat: no, him being possessive and controlling doesn't *prove* he's a murderer or capable of murder. 4. docx from ENGLISH 101 at Cleburne Co High Sch. I also think the late night calls to Hae that SK/Adnan brush off as giving Hae his phone number are more likely a late night desperate plea for Hae to take Adnan … Why would Jay go from Best Buy to Woodlawn High unless he were picking up Adnan and taking him to track practice? Remember that call logs were new and people weren't thinking, "Oh, I better set up … An in-depth analysis of the case of Adnan Syed, including background information, timeline of the crime, recent developments, and key evidence. I thought Sye specifically said that he would have noticed if Adnan had been on time or late. ). Jenn says that Adnan and Jay drove to meet her and she said hi to Adnan when he dropped Jay off. It makes me angry that so much time has passed, because now it will be even harder to … Adnan admitted that he asked Hae for a ride after school on January 13th. Dana notes that … Who is Rabia? Why is she involved in the case? Rabia is the older sister of Adnan's best friend. My opinion, however, gradually began to shift as I … Because why would he want to know I guess and this could lead the listeners to think maybe Adnan was up to something. What does the state (prosecutor) say happened that day? Who is responsible for the … Yeah, why answer that call either but I don't think he'd know it was the police. Why does Koenig spend time examining the Wolfe case? (Answer with 2-3 complete sentences. " The standard actually is whether any reasonable trier … If she thinks he’s guilty-which I think she does-, imagine that, being a woman that actively helped a femicide perpetrator go free. 12, and while I don't know if … Study with Quizlet and memorize flashcards containing terms like What was Adnan's challenge to Sarah?, How did Sarah and Dana's challenge go? How does this contradict what Adnan says?, Do … Test your English knowledge with this 40-question quiz. docx from AA 1Episode 6: The Case Against Adnan Syed Review I think there are many other reasons as to why Adnan Syed is innocent apart from these 3 reasons I have provided, but I really wanted this to … 1. Question: 4. Nisha is someone only Adnan knows and Jay would not have reason to call her. Serial Play list- • Serial & Adnan Syed more 3:38pm called Phil 3:40-3:45pm allegedly the “come and get me call” from Jay’s story 3:55-59pm allegedly called Patrick for weed around … The expert said that ½ of murders have some degree of amnesia but that over they do recover their memories of the event. he’s also a victim of the … Adnan Syed after arrest After listening to the Serial podcast and watching the HBO documentary, The Case Against Adnan Syed, I was leaning towards Adnan’s innocence. Try the exercise below to understand the challenges Adnan faced … Study with Quizlet and memorize flashcards containing terms like 21 minutes, Her younger brother is Adnan's best friend. Will doesn't say specifically whether he remembers seeing Adnan at track. She's consistently said she saw Adnan after school in the library, chatted … Jenn’s account of the evening (24:00) Evidence How it can be used against Adnan Why it may be insignificant Level of significance The Nisha Call 26:30 Calls on pay phone Jay/Adnan answers This was on the day of the murder. until 5:30 - 6:00 p. For those that believe he is innocent, how do you explain the nisha call… The other two seasons weren't interesting enough, so people still think of this as Adnan-Central. In one version, Adnan says it the night before the murder. So Adnan has these three worlds. This episode … Have listened to season 1 and there was one question which I don't think was ever asked of Adnan at all, which I found strange. Adnan had no idea if Sarah was about to reveal that his alibi was a complete shambles. Why were people surprised Adnan was arrested? (Consider how others describe Adnan. Big whoop. And for knowing that Asia was unreliable -- Jay is unreliable and he's … I think there are also subtle hints of jealous behavior from Adnan (the parts where she describes wanting her own life, getting sick of his accusations, etc. He was on the … It wasjust middle class and right beside the city 4. Adnan responds by saying that Stephanie was a close friend and he wanted to make sure she also got a gift from him because she wanted one … Probably not. What does it mean to "spin" something? What pieces of evidence did … The seemingly frantic need of Adnan to be in contact with Hae: It is irrefutably confirmed that Adnan calls Hae multiple times the night before, asks Hae for a ride on the day, and is later inconsistent with … i don’t think Adnan is a villain. Summarize the incident at the mosque, and explain why this part of Adnan’s … Why wouldn't Adnan give a recap of his story that day at all more than he was at the library and track when it was clear through several eye witnesses he was spotted with Jay that day? If I was Adnan … In the first episode when Sarah meets Rabia, Rabia goes on to tell about Adnan being a "community golden boy" who was homecoming king, track star, and volunteer EMT Sarah fact checks this and … It often relies on the testimony of people who knew Adnan, and who were more or less surprised when he murdered Hae. 12. One time Hae got into a car accident and she called both guys and Don told … 1. She doesn't want to write it all off but she doesn't think it drove … That said, why would Jay ask Adnan of all people to borrow his car? It seems like Jay knows lots of people and has lots of friends - why ask someone you claim to barely know to borrow their car? Conversely, if you claim to not really know … What does Jim Trainum, the "real detective", think about how the case was handled? (11:00- 12:52) He thinks the detective's evidence was well documented, even if there is no … I get the feeling that Jay was his Pot/Bad friend. 7. Who does Sarah think called Adnan at “Cathy’s” that night? How does that change our understanding of “Cathy’s” memory? … An in-depth analysis of the case of Adnan Syed, including background information, timeline of the crime, and analysis of the evidence. Jenn told the detectives that she took Jay to throw his clothes out the next day. She believes in … I also lean on the statement from one of the kids on the track team that Adnan was frequently seen with Jay. How might this affect the outcome of the trial? Jay was the State's key witness against Adnan, despite having changed his story at least 6 times, because the police corroborated his story with cell records. What … I think Adnan's phone only calls Jenn when Jay has possession of Adnan's phone and Adnan is not there. Domestic violence, as someone else here wrote, is not just a literary device. Evidence How it can be used against Adnan Why it may be insignificant Level of significance Hae's letter/ Adnan's note to Aisha (7:39) He wrote I will kill on the note. 4:45 pm THE NISHA CALL: Why does Koenig say this call is significant? Do you think there is an explanation for this? … Why do you think Adnan is guilty? For those that still believe in his guilt even with Jays constantly changing stories, the shady detectives with the shady track record and even Kristi admitting to their … Adnan doesn't seem to care what Jay did, or why he did it, while Jay is obviously upset Adnan is denying involvement. The library is a very crowded place so it must have been very hard for Adnan to kill her there. What does Julie ask about the discrepancy between Jay’s and Jenn’s stories? … I don't think Adnan is innocent, mainly based off that I think he would just have to be extremely unlucky to be 100% innocent. . Jay arrives to the scene and that’s when Adnan tells him what happened and shows him the body. If he did the same with Asia, he would include it in his planned alibi. 1. Why do they omit the others? … At the same time, Adnan saying that he does remember having a conversation with his coach about Ramadan that day, and you think that is suspicious as well. If I were to litigate this case, I would not try to build a picture of why he is innocent, … Rate 1 (not important) to 3 (very important) Evidence (Record Details ) How it can be used against Adnan Why it may be insignificant Level of significance "Palm print" on map book … Who did SK (or anyone) think made the anonymous phone call that pointed police to Adnan? I’m relistening to the pod, and in Ep. Study with Quizlet and memorize flashcards containing terms like What important details did jay changed on his versions and why do you think he decided to change his version even though he … Adnan can admit his guilt to his attorney under attorney / client privilege and it be kept secret. I (do or … Study with Quizlet and memorize flashcards containing terms like True, Asia, 1. First of all, it was Jay’s eighteenth birthday, and since … ADNAN’S MOTIVE: Adnan being a “player” doesn’t make us think this relationship wasn’t important to him. His parents didn’t … This does not sound like someone changing the time to match the murder time (and nobody knows when she was murdered). I think this may be why Christina ignored Asia’s alibi because if she explored it and reviewed cameras at the … We will watch the four-part docuseries in class. I suspect Jay was at Jenn's house with Adnan's cel phone and car until after track practice, and then went to pick up Adnan at school. Jay would … 7. 5:30pm: Adnan and Jay agree (except for slight time variations) they went to Cathy’s … Strange, but ok since she didn’t really know them well - How does she describe Adnan: strange, quiet If someone called and told him the … Question: 4. Isn’t it stupidly unlikely that a pocket dial would occur during a murder? The “butt dial theory” has been the subject of scorn because many … 26 votes, 235 comments. Why does Will think it is unlikely that Adnan was late for track? (26:00) Because it was commonplace for him to be there, so he’d obviously know about the resulting consequences if he appeared late. But if anything, the sticky posts should be about upcoming seasons and updates on the other seasons, of … Study with Quizlet and memorize flashcards containing terms like window time that Adnan cannot account for?, who is Rabia?, Why were people surprised that Adnan was arrested? and more. … It's just pretty hard to think that she would be strangled by a fellow teenager in some sort of Best Buy or library parking lot, and Jay is a very shady character with shady testimony, I get all that, but the fact … 5 How does Adnan feel about Cristina Gutierrez 1845 6 What was her defense from LRMS1-UC MISC at New York University Why do people think that Adnan was this helpless innocent who didn't know anything and was passively steered around by other people? Yes, his parents were old-school and strict, and I'm sure this was … Adnan was inquiring about pleas and whatever you think about Asia, clearly understood the state's case to know what had to be tackled. For me this is the … I think that he’s probably guilty but the state definitely violated his right to a fair trial and so he has to be released. Koenig ends by telling us that despite the evidence, she has reasonable doubt that Adnan committed the crime because of his character. If Adnan had track practice at 4:30, the library was on school grounds, and he could not go get anything to eat until sundown, why … English document from Aliso Niguel High, 3 pages, Episode 6: The Case Against Adnan Syed Review "Spin": 1. This is a major problem for Adnan’s case. You think Adnan provided the police with an alternate, presumably exonerating timeline, that he never repeats again, and the police are so scared of the truth they bury it. Episode 1: The Alibi Questions 1. What does Koenig think? (5:30) She doesn't think it is. Exactly, and if track practice was his alibi like Jay said, why not make himself more known at practice, by doing things that stood out, such as showing up 5mins late being forced to run laps then complaining … Enright gives insight into Adnan’s case. trueYou're basing an entire post off Rabia's idealized view. 18. Why does Rabia think Adnan did NOT do it? Summarize her reasoning. Crickets again, followed by the "third person" redirect that I can't believe SK fell for. Dana says that it is possible that they were somewhere else- close to that tower like Patrick’s or a strip mall, but she thinks that they were probably at Leakin Park. But Sarah does not entirely believe … This is an esssential question that reoccurs throughout the entire season and that is why I think this episode does an excellent job at demonstrating how maybe Adnan is guilty. 12th to check with Jay. 3, SK describes the anonymous call that leads detectives to look at … Adnan Syed: Jay’s “Evidence” Hae Min Lee was an 18-year-old girl, finishing her senior year of high school. In one episode Adnan was exchanging letters with a friend who had testified that he had tried to get into Hae's car. Enright gives … Personally, I don't see how that gets explained away by anyone, short of someone working at AT&T in the late '90s explaining why the disclaimer was there and … However, Adnan’s aunt, Rabia, who is an attorney, believes that he has been wrongfully convicted – and she has proof. One other thing I find odd is why the police didn't wait 24 hours for this missing adult. Why? Why? Adnan was wrongfully convicted. But many … Episode 2- The Breakup Notes Last episode: basis supplied by the state prosecutor was that when Hae broke up with Adnan, he couldn't accept it, was so furious and wounded he decided to kill … And just a Pro-tip: If you ever get in trouble with the law, you should hire lawyers who sound and think like The Prosecutors, not ones who sound and think like Undisclosed on the Adnan Syed case. What is his explanation of Jay's version of events? English Class Serial The Alibi Episode 1 1. AND I think the debate is interesting and bonkers. Serial pretty clearly established Adnan was none of the things Rabia said he was. If Adnan didn't do it, HE should have a good theory as to why Jay did. docx from HUM MISC at Berkeley College. They could say that he meant to … (19:00) What happens to this stop when Jay tells this story during the trial? Why does Will think it is unlikely that Adnan was late for track? (26:00) Cell Records Adnan’s case is likely the first to use Cell … Why does Will think it is unlikely that Adnan was late for track? Dana notes that although the State tested 14 cell phone tower sites, they only bring up _________ in trial. track now, which seems like a bad strategy for an alibi, doesn’t it? To be noticeably late like that. It has always made sense to me that Adnan and Jay were more than acquaintances based on … -The cell phone records reveal that Jay and Adnan were together that afternoon based on the calls they make. If there are … Adnan Syed is innocent Adnan Syed is innocent Adnan Syed was wrongfully convicted of killing his girlfriend, on the basis of one witness and some cell phone records. I think there's a connection between Jay's 1/13 story to Jenn - that Adnan dropped him off at the mall - and his statement to police - that Hae's car and body were … Jay has given 3 different stories about when Adnan told him he intended to kill Hae. In his testimony Adnan's dad said there were about 1100 families associated with the mosque. One big question I have, … The prosecution did not even call Becky as part of its case, she was called as a defense witness. Adnan’s petition for appeal is based on ineffective counsel, specifically regarding Asia’s potential alibi for Adnan. Jay … The same friends are called the next Wednesday too. Why does Koenig spend time examining the Wolfe case? In this episode, Koenig reaches out to expert Deirdre Enright who works with Virginia’s Innocence Project. Serial Episode 5: Route Talk Detective … View Episode 9 To Be Suspected Answers. For each episode you will answer questions/take notes in complete sentences to gather … Study with Quizlet and memorize flashcards containing terms like Who is Sarah Koenig?, Why does Sarah interview her cousin Sam, and his friends Tyler and Elliot, at the beginning of episode 1?, … I don’t think that this is the case with Adnan because he said that people usually start to remember details after some time. In our final episode of this series, we look at Adnan Syed’s own words and actions. Adnan was hiding his face and silent on the ground while he was in the apartmentwhich might happen if you are extremely high, but he … With episode 6 of serial podcast, Sarah Koenig takes an in depth look at all of the evidence that works against Adnan’s favor. Have the power to affect not only that specific misogynist but also … Why is the hour before track practice important to the case? that was the time Adnan could be either in the library or outside the school (driving somewhere to bury Hae's body) 15. I'm more concerned about whether the case they made against him is factual … Communications document from Springfield High School, Springfield, 4 pages, Episode 1- The Alibi Case Details: Jan 13th 1999 Hae Min Lee, Sr. People believed that Adnan's case was influenced by racism. Why does Will think it is unlikely that Adnan was late for track? (26:00) Will thinks its unlikely that Adnan was late for track because its … Dana says that it is possible that they were somewhere else- close to that tower like Patrick's or a strip mall, but she thinks that they were probably at Leakin Park. This was the first time Koenig took a deep dive into the star witness’s character traits. Why does Will think it is unlikely that Adnan was late for track?(26:00) Will thinks its unlikely that adnan was late for track because its common that hes always there, and he knows … So it seems unlikely that anyone would notice if Adnan was on time or late. ) People were shocked that Adnan got arrested because he was the golden child of the community. What does Julie think about the 3:21 call? Why is it confusing? (31:24) They say that it's possible that Adnan has the phone not Jay. What does Koenig think? (5:30) I think that Racism was definitely a part of this case. Even Adnan and Don got along. Ideal for practice, review, and assessment with instant feedback on Wayground. Then there's all the possibilities of how much he was actually involved. Why is the post titled Adnan's "I Will Kill" note? I look forward to Susan offering the same argument in retort of the Motion to Vacate based on an anonymous call … View S1E6 Adnan. This is … Based on much that undisclosed has presented, I'd have to say Adnan is innocent. I'm not buying that it was adnan but i agree with her I don't think that this is the case with Adnan, I think he seems perfectly normal and i … If Adnan did this I think he would have sent her an urgent page to meet him somewhere more private. i also speculate— and i hate to do it— that he is a victim of complex trauma. When he's not expressing anger, he must know Jay's right. Adnan and Jay suddenly left to attend to whatever was going on. The "C" is the "C" number. The Police interview Adnan’s friend Ju’uan who says they sometimes went to Best Buy to smoke because “Nobody’s going to be over there”. The cell tower that originates … Episode 10: The Best Defense is a good Defense This episode examines key aspects of Adnan’s trial including the possible influence of racism, Gutierrez as a lawyer, and other revelations during the trial. ) She spends time … I think it's clear that he was involved in a much larger capacity than he has let on and has always lied because he's afraid of going to jail for murder because if he told the truth I think he'd most certainly … Your opinion about I think I do agree with this. This makes him look guilty because it indicates that he … Aquí nos gustaría mostrarte una descripción, pero el sitio web que estás mirando no lo permite. Jay stupidly decides to play it out thinking it's highly unlikely … All the subsequent call-log activity on that day does not reconcile with Adnan's initial story of school, track, mosque, home. 8 minutes 5. But what about the Nisha call? This is a significant issue with my hypothesis. It's also weird if it were the 4:27 call, because most people tend to place Adnan … Law document from Eleanor Roosevelt High School, 3 pages, Episode 7: The Opposite of Prosecution Before listening to this episode, familiarize yourself with Wolfe's case. Again, not definitive proof that he murdered her but … But even if Jay’s testimony is corroborated in those respects, that does not mean his testimony provides credible evidence against Adnan. And Adnan might have been closer to those friends, but he probably was closer to … He doesn't recall that the defendant was late for track practice which he said began at 4:00 at trial. 🤨 During the drive, Adnan realized it was God's plan for Hae to only live 18 years, and it made him feel better to think of it like that. Adnan responds by saying that Stephanie was a close friend and he wanted to make sure she also got a gift from him because she wanted one from him. The night before she was killed, Hae was paging Adnan - that's why he called her. 5 minutes 6. Jay says consistently that Adnan dropped him off at home and Jenn came and got him there. ) People were shocked that Adnan got arrested because he was the golden child of the … Unsurprisingly, the standard isn't "does some random person on the internet think the evidence was insufficient after listening to a biased podcast. i think he was young, heartbroken, unsupported, and overwhelmed. But the prosecution does not appear to have raised the issue of Adnan asking for a ride in its cross (assuming there was … But while the jury always has the right to determine whether a witness is telling the truth, it does not appear that, in this case, there was any objective basis for crediting Jay’s testimony against Adnan (as discussed in … 13. She believes that Adnan is innocent and that the lawyer threw the case on purpose 3. Why is this significant? (7:00) This is significant because it supports the idea that Adnan might have been familiar with Best Buy as a secluded spot, which ties into Jay’s claim that Adnan called him … The prosecution's own timeline doesn't work because they have Hae being killed during a tiny time window and dying while Adnan is still in the library. What do … 49 votes, 419 comments. For that matter, why do some Adnan supporters still think that Jay killed Hae? (1) It's not possible for Jay to have killed Hae by himself or somebody else, and (2) even Adnan's own defense team abandoned … • Adnan calls and says Hae is dead and he's at B est Buy • When he gets to Best Buy, Adnan opens Hae's trunk and to show Hae's body and they ditch the car then hang out (buy … People believed that Adnan's case was influenced by racism. What does Koenig do to try and verify Asia’s story? Do you think she has taken the … If Adnan (or Adnan and Jay) went to Bilal's in the late morning/early afternoon on January 13, what do you think would be the purpose? 11. Sarah says some people think Adnan was proven to be “duplicitous”, or deceitful, because of his bad behavior at the mosque. Adnan had track practice that day and competed the next day in a meet, he ran a relay race— it would have been conspicuous if he missed practice … I think that this is very suspicious on Adnan’s part, as the podcast states that many important events occurred during that day. I get why it’s important if you think adnan did it. docx from ENGLISH 5/6 at Mark Keppel High. One of the biggest being Adnan’s palm print on a map of … If Saad had told Adnan’s parents about Adnan’s relationship around the Junior Prom timeframe, the relationship most likely would never have had an opportunity to blossom given how intrusive Adnan’s … Reasons Why Adnan is Innocent Reason 1 1 There is an alibi. I think the op wants to highlight the dumb decisions that Adnan made, also known as the evidence against him. pdf from DP 111 at Mandela International Magnet School. Adnan responds by saying that Stephanie was a close friend and he wanted to make sure she also got a gift … You would think with Asia's very recent ("during the trial") visit with Adnan's mother fresh on his and his wife's mind he would have mentioned that visit either in his testimony or the RC-authored letters he signed onto in the weeks following … It’s important because it alludes to the fact that Adnan’s lawyer didn’t actually care about helping him, she was just scamming him just to make some money. Who is Rabia? would. This wasn't used in the case because she kept changing her … But I don't know why she would've made that up, and we do know that she had an away basketball game that day. Adnan has made … Episode 10: The Best Defense is a good Defense This episode examines key aspects of Adnan’s trial including the possible influence of racism, Gutierrez as a … Why Adnan Got a Cellphone In addition to obtaining the call records for Adnan’s cellphone, investigators also obtained phone records for … You didn't think that I would remember? Or did you just totally forget yourself?" Adnan says now that he does in fact remember seeing Asia in … The midterm will be our final test for Serial and Adnan's case Learn with flashcards, games, and more — for free. If so, it explains most of the call log. at Woodlawn High School … 81 votes, 348 comments. … It was conceived as propaganda. … 11. As noted on the … How it supports the motive Why it could be unimportant to the case/ fails to support the motive Overall, is the evidence valuable? (Consider how this portrays Adnan inlight of the proposed motive) Stuff in Hae's diary about her … 14 What do you think 2 Episode 10 The Best Defense is a good Defense 15 Koenig from LRMS1-UC MISC at New York University Why doesn’t Adnan remember that day? Hi all! I feel like every post prefaces with their stance, so: I think Adnan is guilty. This literally has zero bearing … As I said earlier, a horrible imagine was painted of Adnan which is why I think his parents appreciated this podcast. mlgo grrmrru zsce irac rgldgfgm xhamgg fgns vyqhkg ffqn ogo